Author Archives: John Lusk

I don’t think this post needs a title. Y’all figure it out.

«And who, he asked, would be the site supervisor? A bearded man in Ray-Ban sunglasses and a Norfolk State University sweatshirt stepped forward.

“What’s your name, sir?” Jones asked.

“Devon Henry.”

“Devon Hen—” Jones began, then dropped his voice respectfully. “Oh, Mr. Henry. Of course.”»

https://www.washingtonpost.com/dc-md-va/2023/01/02/devon-henry-confederate-statues-richmond/

ActivityPub moderation, federation decisions

I was invited by @futurebird (thanks!) to participate/join/comment in a discussion of moderation software, arising from a post by @cd24@sfba.social. I’m not actually a moderator and I don’t know what the current toolset offers, but I keep toying with the idea of running something in the fediverse which would probably really have need of moderation, so I sometimes turn over moderation thoughts in my head. (Run-on sentence, sorry; deep breath.) Plus, I’m really interested in the topic.

Thoughts that popped into my head (trying not to repeat what others have already said in this thread), with no particular organization:

  • It should be easy to coalesce reports or deal with them in aggregate. One thing that would help is good keyboard shortcuts. If I get 60 reports about a user, it would be nice to be able to mass-select them and take some action, using a “select all” checkbox, but also, if “select all” is too broad, something like tab-space-tab-space-tab-space-etc. Not that I necessarily want to do that 60 times, but at least it’s better than n x 60 x mouse-target-click, for some n >= 1.
  • There are probably better ways to aggregate/coalesce (e.g., search/filter), but that seems like a reasonable minimum.
  • Really, good keyboard equivalents everywhere, but that’s just a minimum, right?
  • Bearing in mind harassment, it would be nice to see the reporter’s history and maybe relation to other reporters.
  • Some way of highlighting patterns. Maybe moderation decisions/reasons as tags, for both reporter and report subject? Would affect displays of historical info.
  • I think, for an admin, moderation decisions are associated with defederation/possible-refederation decisions, so some (easy) way to track moderation issues associated with particular instances (e.g., frequency of reports, frequency of problematic users, both within configurable timeframes) and monitor defederated instances for improvement (if desired) (e.g., reported posts taken down, acceptable apologies (maybe? I know some people aren’t in the mood), reported users banned).

#mastodon #mastoAdmin #moderation

“Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity.”

Someone posted a one-liner to Mastodon and I felt compelled to look it up.

«From all that I have attempted to say it should now be apparent that sincerity and conscientiousness in themselves are not enough. History has proven that these noble virtues may degenerate into tragic vices. Nothing in all the world is more dangerous than sincere ignorance and conscientious stupidity. Shakespeare wrote:

For sweetest things turn sourest by their deeds; 
Lilies that fester smell far worse than weeds.

As the chief moral guardian of the community, the church must implore men to be good and well-intentioned and must extol the virtues of kindheartedness and conscientiousness. But somewhere along the way the church must remind men that, devoid of intelligence, goodness and conscientiousness will become brutal forces leading to shameful crucifixions. Never must the church tire of reminding men that they have a moral responsibility to be intelligent.

Must we not admit that the church has often overlooked this moral demand for enlightenment? At times it has talked as though ignorance were a virtue and intelligence a crime. Through its obscurantism, closedmindedness, and obstinacy to new truth, the church has often unconsciously encouraged its worshipers to look askance upon intelligence.

But if we are to call ourselves Christians, we had better avoid intellectual and moral blindness. Throughout the New Testament we are reminded of the need for enlightenment. We are commanded to love God, not only with our hearts and souls, but also with our minds. When the Apostle Paul noticed the blindness of many of his opponents, he said, “I bear them record that they have a zeal for God, but not according to knowledge.” Over and again the Bible reminds us of the danger of zeal without knowledge and sincerity without intelligence.»

Martin Luther King, Jr., Strength to Love

No, Software-Bricked Tractors Thwarting Russian Looters Is Not A Sign That Either John Deere Or Copyright Is Good

«it’s not like the Russians will be returning any of these tractors to their rightful owners now that they’ve found they can’t use them. Simply depriving Ukrainians of their own property is a huge blow to them, and the looters may still profit from their thievery by scavenging the tractors for parts and raw materials. So it’s not like John Deere and its embedded software, or the copyright in that software that gives it such control over its sold machines, have managed to right a serious wrong.»

https://www.techdirt.com/2022/05/05/no-software-bricked-tractors-thwarting-russian-looters-is-not-a-sign-that-either-john-deere-or-copyright-is-good/